Dear anyone,
Your duolingo forum registration isn't automaticaly transferred to duome forum so in order to join duome forums you need to register with your existing or any other username and email; in any case it's advised that you choose a new password for the forum.
~ Duome Team

[ARCHIVE] Kol (כל) / Be'chol (בכל) & other consonant sound changes

Moderator: Corinnebelle

User avatar
Corinnebelle

[ARCHIVE] Kol (כל) / Be'chol (בכל) & other consonant sound changes

Post by Corinnebelle »

Skoubi_Doo wrote:

Hello everyone!
I couldn't find any discussion related to my questions so here we go!
I read in some grammar book that the letters ב Bet, כ Kaf and פ Peh always have a hard sound (occlusive) when at the beginning of a word or a syllable. In the other cases, they are pronounced as fricative. Okay. I guess this could then explain why we have כל (kol) and בכל (be'chol), or things like panim / le'fanim לפנים / פנים
How to explain these sound changes? The fact that bet/kaf/peh has changed position? The presence of the preposition itself? If so, does it work like this with ALL the prepositions?
Besides, I noticed some things that puzzle me, like:
אני הולך לבית הספר pronounced both "le'veit ha'sefer" and "le'beit ha'sefer" on Forvo
but I have heard בבית only pronounced "ba'bait" so far (and never "ba'vait")
I heard someday a woman say שלום לכולם "shalom le'Kulam”, and someone else say “shalom le'CHulam” on some other day
in a Mizrahi song I heard וכשאני שר לה "u'CH'she'ani shar la”, but וכשהכל נגמר "u'K'she'hakol nigmar” in another song (not Mizrahi)
These are just a couple of examples... I hope I am being clear!
I think I am not wrong thinking that לכל ,בכל, etc. are always pronounced “be'chol” and “le'chol”, and that no one would pronounce "be'kol" or "le'kol" (but who knows...), but then my question is: why all these variations (that I mentioned above)?
Are they dialectal variations? Language register variations? Just alternatives? Or could this be explained by some grammar rule?
Despite all my Hebrew material I couldn't find any satisfying explanation... Also, maybe I am too early in the Hebrew tree (I will soon start Present 3). So if you have an answer, or a link to a related discussion that I might have missed on Duolingo, feel free to share and/or to correct me!
תודה רבה ו...שלום לכולם! :)

Archive of comments

If you don't want your post on here, please let me know.

🇺🇸 L1 🇮🇱 Advanced beginner Duolingo levels

Languages without borders, languages bridging gaps, the Red Cross are my heroes.

Return to “Alefbet”